Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 5 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
The Claims of Rome and Eastern Orthodoxy  /  Mary  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 5
At Cana (John 2), Bercot reads Jesus’ “Woman, what do I have to do with you?” as a rebuke and distancing rather than obedience to Mary; what do you make of his claim that Jesus was “nipping in the bud” human tendencies to exalt Mary, and how does that reframe the way you interpret Jesus’ tone toward family relationships?
Another way to ask: At Cana, Bercot thinks Jesus’ words to Mary sound like a correction, not giving in to her. Do you agree that Jesus was stopping people from over-honoring Mary, and how does that change how you read Jesus’ tone toward family?

Direct Answer Bercot’s claim suggests Jesus intentionally guarded His mission and authority from being controlled by family ties and also prevented future believers from overexalting Mary. It reframes Jesus’ tone as purposeful boundary-setting: honoring Mary’s needs without granting her spiritual authority over Him.

Support from Transcript:

  • He quotes Cana: Mary says “They have no wine,” and Jesus replies, “Woman, what am I to do with you? Mine hour has not yet come.”
  • He argues the phrase “What do I have to do with you?” is “always a form of rebuke,” offering OT/NT examples (2 Sam 16:9; Mark 1:23–24).
  • He says the passage “suggest[es] just the opposite” of Jesus obeying Mary; Jesus is “distancing himself… making it clear that he doesn't do her bidding.”
  • He notes Mary’s response is submission: “Whatever he says unto you, do it… she backs out of the picture.”
  • He emphasizes Jesus always addressed Mary as “woman,” not “mother,” and denies this was mystical exaltation since He addressed other women the same way.
  • He interprets Jesus’ intent: “Even though you're my earthly mother, I am your Creator… Lord… God,” and He was “nipping in the bud” tendencies to exalt or worship her.
Discussion Follow-ups How do you distinguish honoring parents from giving them spiritual authority over Christ’s lordship? What boundaries does Jesus model for family influence in ministry?

Jumpstarter 5 of 10
Back Questions Next