Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion

Question 10

Bercot argues incense and prayers to saints entered after Constantine through unconverted pagans bringing old habits and receiving “Christian rationalizations,” and he says true worship is a “reform of the morals” and prayer from a “chaste body…unstained soul…sanctified spirit”; what concrete changes to worship habits, personal prayer, and moral seriousness would follow if we accepted his claim that God is not impressed by religious aesthetics but by holiness?

Another way to ask: If Bercot is right that God cares more about holiness than religious beauty, what specific changes should that bring to our worship habits, our personal prayer, and how seriously we take living right?

Direct Answer If we accept Bercot’s claim, worship would shift away from sensory religious “adds” and toward inward purity, direct prayer to God through Christ, and a stronger focus on moral reform as the true “sweet fragrance” God desires.

Support from Transcript:

He quotes early writers: “God has no need…of…incense” (Justin) and God is “himself perfect fragrance” (Athenagoras).
Clement redefines incense as the heart: “An odor of a sweet fragrance is the heart that glorifies him,” and says holy prayer is the true incense.
Minucius Felix (quoted as “To Julian” in the transcript) contrasts true sacrifice—“prayer dispatched from the chaste body, an unstained soul, and a sanctified spirit”—with “few grains of incense.”
Lactantius: God is not appeased by “incense, victims, or costly offerings,” but by “a reform of the morals.”
On saints, Origen insists “every prayer…is to be sent up to the supreme God” through the Word; Bercot says there is “no record” ante-Nicene of praying to saints.

Discussion Follow-ups What worship “aesthetics” might you be tempted to trust to make worship feel real? What would measurable “reform of morals” look like in a congregation over the next year?

Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Add your phone number?

Thank you!

Jumpstarter 10 of 10