Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in
Question 2
In David’s conversation with his evangelical pastor about Romans 8:35–39, he argues the passage doesn’t say “I can’t sever my relationship with Christ” but only that no third party can make Christ stop loving him; what do you think is at stake spiritually and pastorally in that distinction, and how would it reshape the way you talk about assurance, apostasy, and repentance?
Another way to ask: Does Romans 8:35–39 mean no one else can stop Christ from loving me, or that I myself can’t walk away from Him? Why does that difference matter for how we talk about assurance, falling away, and repentance?

Direct Answer The transcript suggests the stake is whether Romans 8 is used to promise unconditional security regardless of disobedience, or whether it is read as encouragement to remain faithful in suffering. Pastorally, David’s distinction pushes assurance toward persevering love and obedience, and it keeps open the real need for repentance rather than assuming nothing we do can endanger our relationship with Christ.

Support from Transcript:

  • David’s pastor used Romans 8:35–39 as a “key passage” for “unconditional eternal security.”
  • David replied it “doesn’t say that I can’t sever my relationship with Christ. It only says that no third party can cause Christ to stop loving me.”
  • He critiques the pastor’s comeback (“Oh, I suppose I can do something that even an angel can’t do”) as “not an honest argument.”
  • He says if Paul meant “nothing we can do” could separate us, Paul would have listed sins like “murder or adultery…rob and slander,” but he did not.
  • He later links abiding in Christ’s love to obedience: Jesus says “Whoever…keeps [my commandments]…will be loved,” and “If you keep my commandments, you will abide in my love.”
Discussion Follow-ups How can a church speak strong comfort to suffering believers (Romans 8) while still warning seriously about disobedience and the need to “abide” (John 15)?