Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion

Question 10

Leonard Shimer’s “Potion in the Bottle” describes a drink that makes someone “different,” with “no concern for money or life,” produced by a heart “crushed by the mortar called the cross,” and he wrote it shortly before dying for his faith—how would early Anabaptists have understood this “cross-crushed” Christianity, and what would have to change in our churches for neighbors to “take notice” in the way Shimer describes?

Another way to ask: How would early Anabaptists have understood Shimer’s picture of being changed by a “cross-crushed” life with no concern for money or even life itself? What would need to change in our churches for neighbors to notice that kind of difference today?

Direct Answer The transcript portrays early Anabaptists like Shimer as understanding Christianity as a cross-formed transformation that visibly changes a person’s priorities—so much that outsiders notice their loosened grip on “money or life.” For neighbors to take notice today, our churches would need more real surrender that produces observable difference, not merely religious talk.

Support from Transcript:

Shimer reports outsiders’ accusations: believers “drink something out of a bottle” and then “isn’t happy with ordinary life anymore… has no concern for money or life.”
He agrees there is a real change: “whoever drinks from that bottle becomes a different person, and his neighbors take notice.”
He defines the “drink” as inner crucifixion: “the smashed, beaten, ground-up, and troubled heart, crushed by the mortar called the cross.”
Bercot notes Shimer was “an early Anabaptist leader who died for his faith,” showing this was not theoretical.
Earlier in the chapter, Bercot ties kingdom life to “real surrender” and daily self-denial, which fits Shimer’s “different person” result.

Discussion Follow-ups What would neighbors notice if our hearts were truly “crushed by… the cross”—how we treat money, comfort, and conflict? Are we content with commitments that change our beliefs but not our visible way of life?

Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Add your phone number?

Thank you!

Jumpstarter 10 of 10