Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 4 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 4
Henry Scugall describes love for God as “a delightful and affectionate sense of the divine perfections” that “surrender[s] and sacrifice[s]” the whole self; how does that definition challenge fear-based obedience or mere duty, and what would have to change in a person’s inner life for that kind of love to become normal?
Another way to ask: Scugall says loving God is a joyful, deep love that leads you to give your whole self to Him. How does that challenge obeying out of fear or just duty, and what would need to change inside you for that kind of love to feel normal?

Direct Answer Scugall’s definition challenges fear and duty by describing love as delight, affection, and wholehearted surrender; for it to become normal, a person must move from mere rule-keeping to communion with God as their joy and chief desire.

Support from Transcript:

  • Scugall: love is “a delightful and affectionate sense of the divine perfections,” not anxious compliance.
  • It “makes the soul surrender and sacrifice itself wholly unto Him,” which goes beyond external behavior.
  • It “desires above all things to please Him” and “delights in nothing so much as… fellowship and communion with Him.”
  • Bercot explicitly says love is not the main driver behind “fear obedience and dutiful obedience.”
  • He describes Jesus’ model: “Jesus’ entire delight, focus, and life is in His Father,” and “My food is to do the will of Him who sent me.”
  • He notes this change is gradual: surrendering to love “does not come easily or happen overnight… lots of setbacks,” yet “through the power of Christ” it can happen.
Discussion Follow-ups What would change if your main motivation shifted from “I must obey” to “I want to be with Him and please Him”?