Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 5 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 5
David says we “give to the poor… God’s money… not our own,” yet “God turns around and rewards us for the dishonest thing we’ve done”; in what sense is this “dishonest,” and what does this reveal about God’s mercy, generosity, and willingness to credit us for what was already His?
Another way to ask: David says giving to the poor is giving away God’s money, yet God still rewards us for it. Why would that be called “dishonest,” and what does it show about God’s mercy and generosity?

Direct Answer In David’s framing, the “dishonesty” is that we give away resources that aren’t truly ours—God’s property—yet we receive gratitude and even eternal reward as if it were our own generosity. This reveals a God who is remarkably generous, willing to commend and reward us for merciful use of His possessions.

Support from Transcript:

  • David says God “allows us to give His property away to others and then turns around and commends us for doing it.”
  • He explains the ownership issue: “everything we think we possess on earth is really God’s.”
  • He notes we built our wealth using creation: “We’ve accumulated our possessions using His resources.”
  • Therefore, “when we give to the poor, we’re actually giving His money to the poor, not our own.”
  • The twist: “Yet the poor are grateful to us for giving them God’s money. And God turns around and rewards us for the dishonest thing we’ve done.”
  • He says this mirrors Luke 16 where “the master commended the unjust steward because he had dealt shrewdly.”
Discussion Follow-ups Does it bother you that God would “credit” us for giving away what was already His? How might that shape gratitude (not pride) when we give?