Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 2 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Salvation: Mechanical or Relational?  /  Atonement Part 3: Common Questions  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 2
In Bercot’s summary, the satisfaction model makes “the barrier…primarily God,” while the early Christian model says “it wasn’t God’s heart that needed to be changed, it was our nature”; what does each model imply about God’s character—especially His readiness to forgive, His holiness, and what He is trying to accomplish in salvation?
Another way to ask: If the main problem is God’s barrier (satisfaction model) versus our broken nature (early Christian model), what does each view say about what God is like—His forgiveness, holiness, and goal in saving us?

Direct Answer Bercot presents the satisfaction model as implying God is not able to forgive until His justice is satisfied, while the early Christian model implies God “always stood ready to forgive,” yet His holiness requires that sinners be cleansed and transformed to have fellowship with Him.

Support from Transcript:

  • Satisfaction model: “the barrier…was primarily God,” and Christ’s death “changed the heart of the Father,” because “His justice would not allow him to simply forgive.”
  • In that model, Bercot says, “man is no different after the Atonement…he still lives in sin,” but has “a new legal standing.”
  • Early Christian model: “it wasn’t God’s heart that needed to be changed, it was our nature that had to be changed.”
  • He states, “God always stood ready to forgive,” and “did forgive those who truly repented,” but “sin…alienates us from God.”
  • His skunk illustration: the problem isn’t God refusing relationship; the sinner needs cleansing before close fellowship is possible.
  • He emphasizes God’s holiness: “A holy God cannot have close fellowship with a person who is unholy,” tying this to James: “Cleanse your hands…purify your hearts.”
Discussion Follow-ups How do these two pictures affect prayer and repentance—do you come to God as One who must be placated, or as a Father ready to forgive but calling you to be made clean?

Jumpstarter 2 of 10
Back Questions Next