Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Romans Commentary Chapters 1-8  /  What Romans is All About – Part 1  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 10
The speaker traces “reinventing Romans” from Gnostics to Augustine to Luther—especially Augustine making “total depravity” and predestination central, and Luther redefining “works of the law” as “any of God’s commandments”; which of those claims most directly challenges the way you currently talk about obedience, assurance, and “legalism,” and what concrete changes would it require in how you preach the gospel to yourself and others?
Another way to ask: Which claim about how Romans has been “re-read” (by Gnostics, Augustine, or Luther) most challenges how you think about obedience, assurance, and “legalism”? What would you need to change in how you explain the gospel to yourself and others?

Direct Answer Based on the transcript, Luther’s redefinition of “works of the law” most directly challenges modern talk about obedience and “legalism,” because it turns Paul’s argument about Mosaic boundary markers into a blanket suspicion toward obedience to Christ. Concretely, it would require distinguishing initial salvation by grace through faith from the ongoing necessity of “godly fruit,” and refusing to label calls to obedience as automatic “works righteousness.”

Support from Transcript:

  • Luther claimed “the works of the law” are “any of God’s commandments, including those given by Christ,” rather than circumcision, dietary laws, Sabbath regulations, sacrifices, etc.
  • The speaker says Luther changed a real first-century issue into an “imaginary conflict between law and the gospel.”
  • Luther also “created a conflict between faith and works,” teaching works play “no role” in salvation.
  • The speaker responds: Paul agrees works are not needed for “initial salvation,” but Romans teaches God “will render to every man according to his works… by perseverance in good work…”
  • Because of Luther, “works has become a negative word,” and if someone teaches “obedience to Christ is necessary for our ultimate salvation,” it is called “legalism” or “works righteousness.”
Discussion Follow-ups If you stopped using “legalism” as a quick shutdown word, how would your self-talk change when you fail, and how would your evangelism change when calling someone to follow Christ faithfully?

Jumpstarter 10 of 10
Back Questions Done