Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 6 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 6
Bercot describes reading large portions of Washington’s six-volume diary and finding “complete absence” of prayer, God, spiritual reflection—even on Sundays and Christmas; what do you think a person’s private record (when “you’re not expecting anyone else to ever read it”) reveals about the heart, and how does Jesus’ teaching on secrecy (prayer in secret, giving in secret) sharpen that question?
Another way to ask: Bercot says Washington’s private diary has almost no prayer or spiritual thoughts. What do you think a private journal shows about a person’s heart, and how does Jesus’ teaching about doing things “in secret” affect that?

Direct Answer Bercot argues that a private diary is strong evidence of what someone truly values, because it’s not written to impress others; Washington’s diary reads like a record of weather, travel, and social events with no spiritual life. The transcript does not mention Jesus’ teaching on secrecy, but it does support the idea that private life can expose what is real.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot says he read “large portions from each of the six volumes” and noticed “complete absence of any reference to God, let alone to Jesus Christ.”
  • Even focusing on “entries…for Sundays,” he found “very few references to his even attending church” except during the presidency.
  • When Washington did attend, there’s “never a reference…concerning what the sermon was about…music…service…anything else to indicate that he got anything out of it.”
  • He states, “throughout all six volumes, I never found a reference about prayer, about God, about any spiritual subject.”
  • He argues diaries “carry much more weight than letters and speeches,” since public documents can be “dress[ed]…up,” but diaries are a “personal record of…true inner feelings.”
  • He notes even Christmas entries: no mention of “church…birth of Jesus Christ,” and “Doesn’t even mention it’s Christmas.”
Discussion Follow-ups If someone read our private calendars, texts, or journals, what would they conclude we actually care about most?