Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 3 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 3
Patrick and Marcus “confessed their sins to one another,” and Patrick admits he withheld a “very serious sin” from when he was fifteen; what assumptions about repentance, transparency, and the ongoing moral weight of pre-conversion sins are built into that practice?
Another way to ask: Patrick and Marcus confess sins to each other, but Patrick hides a serious past sin. What does this say about how they view repentance, honesty, and whether sins from before becoming a Christian still matter?

Direct Answer Their practice assumes that confession is part of real friendship and spiritual growth, and that hiding sin is a problem even if it happened before conversion. It also assumes pre-conversion sin still matters morally and can weigh on a believer’s conscience, so bringing it into the light is important.

Support from Transcript:

  • Patrick and Marcus “prayed and read Scripture together” and “even confessed their sins to one another,” treating confession as normal Christian discipleship.
  • Patrick says, “we've been confessing our sins to one another,” implying an ongoing pattern, not a one-time event.
  • He admits he “held back” one sin, calling it “a very serious sin,” suggesting that concealment is inconsistent with the honesty they aim for.
  • He connects the sin to his unconverted state: “I committed it when I was only fifteen… I neither knew God nor hardly believed in Him,” yet he still feels responsible enough to confess.
  • “The two men wept and prayed together,” implying repentance includes grief and turning to God, not merely information-sharing.
  • The narrator notes the confession later has impact: “If only Patrick had known what impact his confession would have years later,” showing confession can have lasting consequences.
Discussion Follow-ups How should Christians handle confession wisely when it could later be used against them? What’s the difference between healthy transparency and unnecessary self-exposure?