Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 2 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Intimacy with God  /  Chapter 21: Can the Rich Be Saved  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 2
The disciples asked, “Who can be saved?” not because they had money, but because they realized they had not fully renounced “materialistic desires”; what does this imply about how Jesus defines “the rich,” and how would an early Christian community have examined someone’s heart to detect that kind of hidden “richness”?
Another way to ask: What does it mean that the disciples felt “rich” because of their desires, not their money? How could an early church tell if someone had this hidden “richness” in their heart?

Direct Answer The transcript implies Jesus defines “the rich” not only as those who possess wealth, but also as those “teeming with materialistic desires,” meaning inner attachment can make someone rich even if they’re poor outwardly. The transcript doesn’t give a step-by-step church process for examining hearts, but it points to examining desires, attachments, and whether a person is willing to renounce what hinders salvation.

Support from Transcript:

  • The disciples were “alarmed” not because they were wealthy (they had left “nets… boats”), but because they realized they had “not yet fully renounced their materialistic desires.”
  • The chapter states plainly: “Both the person who possesses wealth and the one who is teeming with materialistic desires are the rich.”
  • Salvation is for “pure souls free from fleshly desires,” suggesting the real issue is inner desire.
  • Jesus’ call involves preferring Christ over “parents and children and wealth,” and being willing to leave what hinders following him.
  • The internal “persecution” description reveals what to look for: “irreverent lusts, diverse pleasures, earthly hopes… always grasping for more.”
Discussion Follow-ups If “hidden richness” is desire-driven, what kinds of conversations or confessions would help make those desires visible? How would we distinguish normal needs from being “always grasping for more”?

Jumpstarter 2 of 10
Back Questions Next