Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 9
In discussing research, he warns that many “academic” works are rewarded for analyzing and theorizing rather than “just stick[ing] to the facts,” and he urges reading footnotes to see whether sources are primary or just other books; how should this change the way your group chooses Bible study tools, pastors, podcasts, and commentaries—and what sources would you stop trusting if you applied his test?
Another way to ask: How should his warning about “academic” sources change what study tools, pastors, podcasts, and commentaries you trust? If you checked footnotes for real sources, who or what might you stop relying on?

Direct Answer Bercot’s guidance would push a group to prioritize tools that regularly cite and engage primary sources (Scripture itself and early Christian writings for historical questions), and to distrust resources that mainly recycle other modern authors. It would also mean checking prefaces and footnotes instead of assuming credibility based on popularity, academic tone, or lots of citations.

Support from Transcript:

  • “Number one rule… use primary sources” to “ferret out the truth on any historical subject.”
  • Primary source: created by people “who lived at the time,” “not… modified by someone else’s interpretation.”
  • He says secondary sources can help, but shouldn’t replace primary sources; he urges readers to use footnotes to “go right back into the primary sources.”
  • He warns: don’t be fooled by “a lot of footnotes”; ask whether they cite primary sources or “other people’s books.”
  • If footnotes mostly cite other books, it’s “actually a tertiary source… hearsay on top of hearsay.”
  • He advises reading the author’s “preface… most important part” to learn methodology and biases.
Discussion Follow-ups What would it look like to “audit” your favorite teachers: What primary sources do they actually use? Which of your current tools function mainly as tertiary summaries that tell you what you already want to hear?

Jumpstarter 9 of 10
Back Questions Next