Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 1
David Bercot says the Anabaptists were “unique” because they sprang out of the Reformation rather than primitive Christianity or medieval Catholicism; what does that suggest about God’s ability to preserve “Kingdom Christianity” even inside movements that are reforming the church but still deeply entangled with the state?
Another way to ask: Bercot says the Anabaptists came out of the Reformation, not earlier Christianity or medieval Catholicism. What does that say about God keeping “Kingdom Christianity” alive even in church reform movements that are still tied to the state?

Direct Answer Based on David Bercot’s teaching, the Anabaptists show that God can raise up Kingdom Christianity even inside a reform movement that is still tied to state power—by pushing some people beyond “reform” into simple, literal obedience to the New Testament.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot says the Anabaptists were “unique… [because] the Anabaptists sprung out of the soil of the Reformation,” unlike earlier Kingdom groups that came from primitive Christianity or medieval Catholicism.
  • He describes Zurich’s Reformation as deeply state-directed: the “civil magistrates… assumed the governing… rights” of bishops and even “confiscated all of the property formerly owned by the Church.”
  • The first Anabaptists arose from Zwingli’s circle—men he had “turned… to the Bible”—yet they concluded Scripture demanded a different kind of church.
  • Their foundation was “to literally follow what the Scriptures say,” especially regarding discipleship and the church being separate from the world.
  • Though the Reformation structures were entangled with the state, God “sent His messengers, Conrad Grebel, and others,” leading to a congregation marked by “repentance… evidenced by newness of life.”
Discussion Follow-ups Does this imply God’s preservation is mainly institutional, or mainly through obedient minorities inside compromised systems? What helps people move from “reform talk” to actual Kingdom practice?