Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 9
Bercot uses Revelation 3:9 (“synagogue of Satan who say they are Jews and are not, but lie”) to argue Jesus did not accept “fleshly Jews” claiming the title “Jew” apart from faith; how should Christians talk about Jewish identity and God’s love without either (a) adopting contempt, or (b) denying the New Testament’s hard lines about unbelief and rejection?
Another way to ask: How can Christians talk about Jewish identity and God’s love without (a) looking down on Jews or (b) ignoring the New Testament’s strong warnings about unbelief? What would careful, faithful speech sound like?

Direct Answer Bercot would have Christians speak honestly in the Bible’s categories: affirm God’s mercy is open (Jews can be “grafted in again” if they don’t continue in unbelief), refuse boasting or haughtiness, and still acknowledge Scripture’s hard judgments on unbelief. The posture he promotes is truth without smugness—since Gentiles stand by faith and can also be cut off.

Support from Transcript:

  • He denies the issue is “anti-Semitic… hating Jews,” calling it “a matter of being honest” about Scripture.
  • Revelation 3:9: Jesus condemns those who “say they are Jews and are not, but lie,” which Bercot ties to rejecting Christ and opposing the gospel.
  • He explains “Jew” as “praised,” saying they “are not praised by God” because they rejected Christ.
  • Romans 11:18–21: Gentiles must “not boast… do not be haughty, but fear… if God did not spare the natural branches, he may not spare you either.”
  • Romans 11:23: Jews “if they do not continue in unbelief, will be grafted in… God is able to graft them in again.”
  • He stresses there is “one olive tree” (one rootstock), so Gentiles depend on Israel’s root and cannot despise it.
Discussion Follow-ups How can you state the New Testament’s warnings about unbelief while also praying, like Paul, for Israel to be saved? What words or attitudes cross the line from biblical clarity into sinful contempt?