Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 7 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 7
Bercot repeatedly insists “it’s not figurative… in reality, those truly born again are Israel, are Jews,” using Galatians 4 (Hagar/Sarah; “cast out the bondwoman”), Galatians 6 (“Israel of God”), and Hebrews 8 (“obsolete” covenant); what modern Christian commitments—about ethnic Israel, land promises, or end-times charts—feel directly threatened by that claim, and why?
Another way to ask: If “born again people are Israel” is meant in a real, not symbolic, way, what modern Christian beliefs feel threatened by that (ethnic Israel, land promises, or end-times charts)? Why do those feel at risk?

Direct Answer Based on Bercot’s teaching, the claim threatens modern systems that place ethnic/national Israel at the center of God’s covenant identity and prophetic timetable, especially approaches that expect a revival of the old covenant order. He argues the old covenant is “obsolete,” earthly Jerusalem is “in bondage,” and believers (Jew and Gentile) are the present “Israel of God,” so land-centered and chart-centered expectations lose their controlling role.

Support from Transcript:

  • He contrasts today’s prophecy culture: bookstore books explaining how OT prophecies are fulfilled in the “modern country of Israel” and predicting what will happen to “modern Israel.”
  • He insists: “It’s not… figuratively, the church is Israel… In reality, those… born again are Israel, are Jews.”
  • Galatians 4: earthly Jerusalem “is in bondage,” but “the Jerusalem above is free… the mother of us all.”
  • Galatians 4 applies “Cast out the bondwoman and her son” to the present conflict of “flesh” persecuting “Spirit,” supporting a transfer of heirship.
  • Galatians 6:15–16: what matters is “a new creation… and… the Israel of God.”
  • Hebrews 8:13: the new covenant “made the first obsolete,” so he says we “shouldn’t be looking back for the old covenant to be revived ever again.”
Discussion Follow-ups If the old covenant is obsolete, what should Christians do with popular end-times schemes built on restoring old-covenant categories? How should “Jerusalem” language be read in light of “the heavenly Jerusalem”?