Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 3 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Encounter Messages  /  The Shepherd of Hermas: Hope for Repentance  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 3
In the vision of the tower, the cracked stones are people who have something against one another and keep only the appearance of peace. Why would hidden resentment be treated so seriously, and how could a church look healthy while carrying those cracks?
Another way to ask: The cracked stones are people who hold something against each other and only look like they are at peace. Why is hidden resentment so serious, and how can a church look fine and still have these cracks?

Direct Answer

The vision treats hidden resentment as a crack in the stone itself, even when nothing shows on the surface. A church can look peaceful while evil thoughts stay in the hearts of its people.

Support from the Message

- Hermas sees stones in the field with cracks right down the middle and asks what they mean. - He learns that these are the ones "who have something against one another in their hearts and are not at peace among themselves." - They have "only the appearance of peace," and when they leave one another, "their evil thoughts remain in their heart." - Tom Kruger says this stone hits him really powerfully. - The contrast is the first group of stones, fitted so closely that the joints could not be seen.

Discussion Follow-up

What is the difference between keeping the peace in public and truly being at peace with someone? Is there anyone you are polite to while still holding something against them?

Jumpstarter 3 of 10
Back Questions Next