Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Divine Mysteries: Exploring the Trinity, Evil, and Human Destiny  /  Jesus and the Father  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 10
In Bercot’s telling, Arius “confused nature and order” by making Jesus subordinate in nature, while Athanasius swung the other way by denying real ongoing subordination and limiting submission texts to Jesus’ earthly life; what do you think is at stake spiritually (not just intellectually) in keeping “same nature” and “real headship” together, and how might this affect everyday discipleship—obedience, humility, and how we relate to authority?
Another way to ask: Bercot says Arius made Jesus lower in nature, while Athanasius denied real ongoing submission and applied those verses only to Jesus’ earthly life. Why does it matter spiritually to hold both “same nature” and “real headship” together, and how could that shape daily discipleship like obedience, humility, and how we respond to authority?

Direct Answer In Bercot’s framework, what’s at stake is preserving the full deity of Christ while also preserving the real Father-Son relationship the New Testament describes—one that includes genuine obedience and headship. Spiritually, that pattern can shape discipleship by normalizing humble submission without treating it as inferiority.

Support from Transcript:

  • He summarizes the early-Christian balance: Jesus is “equal…in nature,” but “subordinate…as to headship,” with “a hierarchy of order or authority.”
  • He says Arius “confused nature and order” and began teaching the Son was “subordinate in nature,” “created out of nothing,” and “not eternal”—which Bercot labels as not the historic faith.
  • He quotes 1 Corinthians 15 about ongoing subjection: “then the Son Himself will also be subject…that God may be all in all,” and Origen says subjection is not “degrading.”
  • Early church language stresses obedience: “Father…commands and the Son…obeys,” and Jesus “serves the will” of the Father.
  • He warns controversy tends to distort original faith through overreaction; keeping both truths is his antidote to polarization.
Discussion Follow-ups The transcript provided doesn’t yet discuss Athanasius directly (it’s truncated), but Bercot’s spiritual point is clear: if Christ’s obedience to the Father is real, then Christian obedience and humility can be treated as Christlike rather than shameful.

Jumpstarter 10 of 10
Back Questions Done