Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 7 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 7
The chapter suggests that repeated speculation can eventually โ€œtake on the ring of truth because so many people are saying it.โ€ What beliefs or assumptions in modern Christianity might we accept mainly because they are widely repeated rather than because they are well grounded?
Another way to ask: The chapter says repeated guesses can start to sound true because many people say them. What beliefs in modern Christianity might we accept mostly because they are often repeated, not because they are well supported?

Direct Answer

The transcript gives one specific example: the claim that 1 Corinthians 11 was only about prostitutes and cultural head-covering customs. Beyond that, it does not list other modern beliefs, but it warns that any widely repeated Christian claim may need to be tested against primary sources.

Support from Transcript

- Bercot says โ€œthe sheer conjecture of some seminary professorโ€ can be repeated โ€œin dozens of books.โ€ - He warns that authors may have โ€œno way of evaluating the accuracyโ€ of the conjecture they repeat. - He says speculation may become accepted because โ€œso many people are saying it.โ€ - His concrete illustration is the popular interpretation of 1 Corinthians 11 as a โ€œfirst-century cultural problem.โ€ - He says the prostitution explanation is โ€œnot based on any historical evidence whatsoever from the writings of the early church.โ€ - He contrasts that conjecture with โ€œthe actual light that the primary sources shed on this subject.โ€

Discussion Follow-ups

A careful discussion should avoid inventing examples not covered in the transcript. The safer question is: which beliefs have we personally accepted without checking their primary evidence?