Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 4 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 4
The chapter claims that scholars may slant Bible translations to fit their preconceptions, and that believers may choose translations that support their own biases or their pastors’ views. How should serious Christians respond to this warning without becoming cynical or suspicious of everything?
Another way to ask: The chapter says Bible translators may let their beliefs affect their work, and believers may choose translations that support their own views or their pastor’s views. How should serious Christians respond to this warning without becoming distrustful of everything?

Direct Answer

Serious Christians should respond by becoming more honest, objective, and willing to examine evidence, not by becoming cynical. The transcript calls for detachment from preconceived beliefs and a sincere desire to know what Scripture really means.

Support from Transcript

- Bercot warns that “scholars do slant their translations of scripture to fit their own preconceptions.” - He also says believers “choose translations that fit our biases or those of our pastors.” - But his solution is not suspicion of everything; it is to approach Scripture with “no other desire than to know what scripture really means.” - He says a person must believe “that he has nothing to fear from truth.” - He compares proper Bible reading to “the same objectivity and detachment with which a title lawyer reads a deed.” - The main barrier he identifies is “preconceived beliefs,” not scholarship itself.

Discussion Follow-ups

The transcript does not provide a method for evaluating translations. However, it does give a spiritual posture: do not manipulate evidence, do not hide from difficult passages, and do not let loyalty to a pastor or tradition decide what Scripture must mean.