Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 2 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 2
David Bercot says many theologians treat Scripture as “a pool of verses” from which to gather support for a theology they already believe; where do modern Christians, including Bible-believing evangelicals, most easily fall into that same habit?
Another way to ask: David Bercot says some theologians use the Bible like a “pool of verses” to support what they already believe. Where do Christians today, even Bible-believing evangelicals, do the same thing?

Direct Answer

The transcript does not specifically discuss modern evangelicals by name, but it says “Bible-believing Christians” can fall into this habit when they approach Scripture with their minds already made up. They do this by collecting proof texts for conclusions they already accept while ignoring passages that challenge them.

Support from Transcript

- Theologians “begin with a preconceived idea that their school of theology is correct.” - They treat Scripture “as a pool of verses from which to gather statements that support their theology.” - They “ignore or explain away verses” that do not fit their system. - The chapter says that “we” pursue truth like trial lawyers when “we begin with our minds already made up.” - It specifically refers to “Bible-believing Christians” needing to use “common-sense principles of interpretation.”

Discussion Follow-ups

A useful application would be to ask where our conclusions were inherited before they were examined. The transcript’s concern is not one denomination only, but any approach that uses Scripture to defend a preset verdict.