Jumpstarter 5 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion

Question 5

Luther said that John’s Gospel, Paul’s epistles—especially Romans, Galatians, and Ephesians—and 1 Peter were the books that “show you Christ,” while calling James “an epistle of straw.” What does this reveal about the danger of letting a theological system decide which parts of Scripture feel most important?

Another way to ask: Luther said John, Paul’s letters, and 1 Peter best “show you Christ,” but called James “an epistle of straw.” What danger does this show about letting our theology decide which Bible books seem most important?

Direct Answer

Bercot uses Luther as an example of the danger that a theological system can cause a reader to elevate some biblical books and disparage others. In the transcript, Luther’s preferences are presented as selective and theologically driven rather than as genuine submission to all Scripture equally.

Support from Transcript

- Luther wrote that John’s Gospel, 1 John, Paul’s epistles, and 1 Peter “are the books that show you Christ.” - He singled out “Romans, Galatians, and Ephesians” as especially valuable. - By contrast, Luther said, “Saint James’ epistle is really an epistle of straw compared to them.” - Bercot says Luther’s prefaces “steered the reader’s attention away from parts of the Bibles that didn’t fit Luther’s theology.” - Bercot argues, “The Bible books Luther disparaged happened to be the very books that didn’t support his theology.” - He concludes that Luther’s Bible was “not Sola Scriptura” because it came with interpretive guidance that shaped readers’ priorities.

Discussion Follow-ups

The transcript does not explore James’s theology in detail. Its main point is that even a Bible translator can subtly teach readers which parts of Scripture to value or discount.

Jumpstarter 5 of 10