Skip to content
The Historic Faith

Jumpstarter 2 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 2
Tertullian says, “What the apostles taught, the disciples of the apostles confirmed.” What level of weight should Christians give to early Christian testimony when it challenges interpretations that are common in our own churches?
Another way to ask: Tertullian says, “What the apostles taught, the disciples of the apostles confirmed.” How much importance should Christians give to early Christian witness when it disagrees with views common in our churches today?

Direct Answer

The transcript suggests Christians should give early Christian testimony serious weight, especially when it comes from churches founded by apostles or apostolic men and when it confirms a plain reading of Scripture. However, Bercot’s stated method still tests interpretations by Scripture, reasonableness, and primary historical sources.

Support from Transcript

- Tertullian says, “What the apostles taught, the disciples of the apostles confirmed.” - He appeals to “churches that were founded by either apostles or apostolic men” as models. - Bercot says the early Christian understanding “gives full meaning to everything Paul has said.” - He contrasts this with “modern interpretations” that “do not” give full meaning to Paul’s words. - His principle number 6 is to “look at the course of performance, how the first several generations of Christians understood the Scripture.” - His principle number 7 says, “To determine the course of performance, always go to the primary sources.”

Discussion Follow-ups

The transcript does not command Christians to accept every early Christian opinion automatically. Its argument is narrower: early testimony should strongly challenge modern interpretations when it is consistent, early, primary, and fits the passage better.