Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 6 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 6
Several early writers Bercot quotes treat Sabbath observance like circumcision—something not required for salvation and even potentially a sign of missing grace (Ignatius: “If we still live according to the Jewish law, we acknowledge that we have not received grace”); what would it look like today for Christians to “live according to the Jewish law” in spirit even if not in form, and why might that be spiritually dangerous?
Another way to ask: Some early writers said keeping the Sabbath like Jews could show you haven’t received grace. What might it look like today to live with a “law” mindset even if you don’t follow all Jewish rules, and why could that be spiritually harmful?

Direct Answer From Bercot’s perspective, “living according to the Jewish law” today would mean returning to a mindset of religious bondage—treating Old Covenant regulations or special days as God-required badges of righteousness. It is spiritually dangerous because it can imply we “have not received grace” and can pull believers away from Christ’s finished work.

Support from Transcript:

  • Ignatius: “If we still live according to the Jewish law, we acknowledge that we have not received grace,” which Bercot applies especially to Gentiles.
  • Justin Martyr says Christians are blamed by Jews because “we do not live after the law and do not observe Sabbaths,” and adds there is “no more need” of Sabbaths “now.”
  • Tertullian ties it to Galatians: Paul “blames the Galatians” for “observing times, days, months, and years,” calling them “abrogated.”
  • Bercot calls the Mosaic law “nailed to the cross… finished,” and says Christians are under “moral laws… reiterated by Christ,” not Jewish ceremonies.
  • He laments “Gentile Christians are turning back to things of the law,” echoing Paul’s “weak and beggarly elements.”
Discussion Follow-ups Where do you see “law-thinking” show up in church culture today—even in non-Jewish forms (rule-keeping as identity, judging others, fear-based spirituality)?