Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 10 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Church Life: AD 150  /  Holidays  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 10
Near the end, Bercot refuses to bind consciences on Christmas (“some abstain completely,” others remember Christ’s birth) and says the goal is to put facts out so believers can make a “wise and appropriate decision”; what would a genuinely “intelligent and spiritual decision” look like in your household or church about holidays (Christmas, Halloween, Valentine’s Day, New Year’s), and what heart-motives would you need to confront to follow through?
Another way to ask: If we shouldn’t force everyone to celebrate Christmas the same way, what would a wise and God-honoring plan for holidays look like in your home or church? What wrong motives in your heart might you need to face to actually follow that plan?

Direct Answer According to the transcript, an “intelligent and spiritual decision” means choosing practices with clear eyes about their origins and effects, refusing rumor-based judgments, and acting from a desire to honor Christ rather than from fear of people, love of pleasure, or merit-earning.

Support from Transcript:

  • Bercot repeatedly says the purpose is to “put the facts out there so you can make a wise and appropriate decision.”
  • On Christmas, he allows liberty: “Some… stay completely away… I have no quarrel,” while others see nothing wrong with remembering Christ’s birth; “I don’t condemn that view either.”
  • He identifies Halloween as a continuation of Samhain and says, “that’s one holiday we want to keep far away from.”
  • He calls Valentine’s Day essentially Lupercalia with a “false Christian name,” and says New Year’s originated as a Roman festival; even if noting the new year isn’t wrong, we should not “imitate the world… on New Year’s Eve.”
  • He models careful motives: oppose error “based on truth and understanding, not on rumor and misunderstanding.”
  • He warns against quick accusations (Santa/Satan; Easter/Ishtar) and urges evidence-based thinking.
Discussion Follow-ups What motive is hardest for you: fear of being “different,” love of tradition, wanting family comfort, or wanting to feel spiritually superior? How might your church pursue unity while allowing different conclusions on disputable customs?

Jumpstarter 10 of 10
Back Questions Done