Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 9 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 9
The lesson lays out three New Testament selection patterns—lot (Matthias), congregational selection with apostolic appointment (Acts 6), and appointment by existing ministers (Titus/Timothy)—and then suggests God may care more about qualifications than method; what might it look like for a church to truly prioritize qualifications like “not a lover of money” and “full of the Holy Spirit” over methods, credentials, or popularity?
Another way to ask: If God cares more about leader qualifications than the exact method of choosing them, what would it look like for a church to focus on traits like “not loving money” and being “full of the Holy Spirit” instead of credentials or popularity?

Direct Answer Based on Bercot’s teaching, prioritizing qualifications would mean a church choosing leaders from men whose lives are already visibly “proved,” spiritually mature, and free from greed—regardless of whether selection happens by vote, lot, or appointment. The focus shifts from the mechanism and credentials to long-term character observed in the local community.

Support from Transcript:

  • He lists three New Testament patterns: lot for Matthias (Acts 1), congregational selection of seven men with apostolic appointment (Acts 6), and ministerial appointment implied in Titus/Timothy (Titus 1:5).
  • Key lesson statement: “Perhaps…God isn’t as interested in the method… but in the qualifications of those leaders whom we do select.”
  • Acts 6 qualifications: men of “good reputation, full of the Holy Spirit and wisdom.”
  • 1 Timothy qualifications: a bishop must be “blameless,” and Bercot highlights a bishop must be “qualified to teach.”
  • Didache 15: “Appoint…bishops and deacons…meek…not lovers of money…truthful and proved.”
  • He connects “not a lover of money” to the bishop handling offerings: the bishop could “misuse the situation,” so greed is disqualifying.
Discussion Follow-ups What practical ways could a congregation “prove” a man’s character over time (especially around money, humility, and family life) before giving him oversight?