Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 2 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Christian Citizenship  /  Five Laws of the Kingdom Life  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 2
Bercot says theologians have created a form of Christianity where “the teachings of Jesus are essentially heretical,” and he adds, “either he’s a heretic or they’re a heretic”—what specific interpretive moves does he point to (dispensations, starting in Romans, Luther’s approach), and which of those moves are most tempting in your own tradition or habits?
Another way to ask: Bercot says some theologians treat Jesus’ teachings as wrong—so either Jesus is wrong or they are. Of the methods he names (dispensations, starting in Romans, Luther’s approach), which ones show up most in your church or in how you read the Bible?

Direct Answer The transcript points to three main moves: (1) treating Jesus’ commands as for another “dispensation,” (2) treating Romans (Paul) as the starting lens so Matthew’s commands feel secondary, and (3) following Luther’s approach of steering readers away from “commandments” toward “grace” language. Bercot argues these moves functionally silence Jesus.

Support from Transcript:

  • He says people avoid Jesus’ laws by claiming Jesus’ teachings are for “a different dispensation… future… or… before the Church Age.”
  • He says many Christians “start in Romans rather than in Matthew,” and that’s why they “know nothing about the Kingdom of God.”
  • He calls Matthew “the most important New Testament book” because it has “more of the direct teachings of Jesus than any other.”
  • He says Luther “disparaged the book of Matthew” and would have moved it “somewhere else,” because Matthew contains “many commandments.”
  • He quotes Luther’s idea: readers shouldn’t be “looking for commandments where they should be looking for grace,” and says this helped create the idea there are “no commandments in the New Covenant.”
Discussion Follow-ups Which habit is strongest for you: filtering Jesus through Paul, treating commands as “not for today,” or assuming “grace” means “no laws”? What would change if Matthew set your default categories?

Jumpstarter 2 of 10
Back Questions Next