Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 6 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Radical Reformation History  /  Lecture 4: The Church Councils and the Pilgrim Church  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 6
After reciting the Nicene Creed, Dean asks whether “creedal Christianity” is Christianity and says the Sermon on the Mount was “crying out to be heard again” while the target moved to “make sure our creed is perfect.” What specific signs in the transcript show the target shift happening, and where might your community subtly treat correct formulations as a substitute for crucified living?
Another way to ask: What clues in the transcript show the focus shifting from following Jesus’ teaching (like the Sermon on the Mount) to getting the creed exactly right? Where might your church treat correct wording as a substitute for a crucified life?

Direct Answer The transcript shows the target shift when doctrinal precision and public party-spirit replace obedience and Christlike living—creeds become the center, and disagreements are enforced with curses and state power. Dean implies communities today do the same when standards, identity, and debates become easier substitutes for “crucified life” and the Sermon on the Mount.

Support from Transcript:

  • Dean says the needed issues “became the target,” and later: “now the creed was the emphasis… make sure our creed is perfect.”
  • He contrasts: “Back here was the Sermon on the Mount, crying out to be heard again… but the target had moved.”
  • Public tribalism: Christians at Ephesus wearing “blue ribbons” vs “green ones,” like elections or sports.
  • The council spirit includes excommunications over “precisely how” the natures of Christ coexist, beyond agreeing “fully divine and fully human.”
  • Anathemas from the Seventh Council curse even “a doubtful mind” regarding images.
  • Dean’s modern parallel: the “white tennis shoes” progression—an issue becomes identity, separation, and speaking evil; he says it’s easier than heart issues and requires less “crucified life.”
Discussion Follow-ups What are our “blue and green ribbons”—signals that mark who is “us” and “them”? Where do we spend more energy on being correct than on becoming like Christ?

Jumpstarter 6 of 10
Back Questions Next