Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion

Question 1

Dean read Martin Luther King Jr.’s “thermometer vs. thermostat” critique of the church and then asked the class the same question; where do you see your own church life (music, dress, economics, mission priorities) quietly “recording popular opinion” rather than “transforming the morae of society,” and what specific evidence would prove it either way?

Another way to ask: In what ways does your church (music, dress, money, and mission) mostly follow what’s popular instead of changing the culture around it? What clear signs would show which one is really happening?

Direct Answer Based on Dean Taylor’s teaching, “recording popular opinion” shows up when the church’s patterns are basically copied from the world (music, dress, economics, and even what we argue about), instead of setting a clear, Christ-centered conviction that changes people and communities.

Support from Transcript:

Dean quotes King: the early church was not “a thermometer that recorded the ideas and principles of popular opinion… [but] a thermostat that transformed the morae of society.”
Dean applies it plainly: “If the world s-sings in a certain way, you'll sing a certain way. If the world dresses a certain way, you'll dress a certain way… economics, you'll copy that.”
He says constant youth debates (“What’s wrong with this music… clothes…?”) can miss the point; the better question is “what’s right about it?”
Evidence of thermostat-life would be “a clear conviction and a voice that points to and glorifies God.”
Evidence of thermometer-life is when church becomes pointless: “If it really sounds like the world… I’d rather stay home and have a pizza.”

Discussion Follow-ups What would an outsider say your congregation is clearly “for”? What habits (spending, entertainment, modesty, evangelism) would most quickly reveal whether you’re copying or transforming?

Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Add your phone number?

Thank you!

Jumpstarter 1 of 10