Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 5 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 5
Six ministers in 1745 pushed to translate and print the 1,400-page Martyrs’ Mirror even though persecution themes “were hardly relevant” in America; what does that decision reveal about how they understood spiritual danger, and what are the “subtle” dangers today that would make a book about martyrdom feel more necessary than it seems?
Another way to ask: Why would leaders print Martyrs’ Mirror in America when they weren’t being persecuted much? What “hidden” spiritual dangers today could make a martyrdom book feel needed anyway?

Direct Answer Dean suggests the ministers believed spiritual danger increases when life is easy, so they used Martyrs’ Mirror to anchor identity and prepare for endurance before pressure arrived. The transcript points to “subtle” dangers like materialism, individualism, and loss of peoplehood—threats that don’t look like persecution but still dissolve faith.

Support from Transcript:

  • In 1745, six ministers wrote to Dutch leaders asking help to translate Martyrs’ Mirror into German.
  • Roth says it seems “odd” because persecution themes were “hardly relevant” since they lived “in freedom of conscience and…peace and liberty.”
  • Dean explains their motive: “We’ve got to get a hold of us as a people…we have to identify ourselves as a people.”
  • He ties it to Van Braght’s burden: “these times are so easy and fat,” and thus spiritually dangerous.
  • Dean emphasizes literature’s role: without such writings, later revival and identity could be lost (he references Hutterite literature preserving later revival).
Discussion Follow-ups What “easy and fat” pressures today (comfort, entertainment, consumerism, independence) make endurance harder? What would be the equivalent of Martyrs’ Mirror for forming your church’s identity now?