Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in
All Questions
Question 5
The slideshow’s “social ladder” picture portrays Mennonites rising from a persecuted church to “practically royalty,” including a man “knighted” for wealth; where do you see the turning point in that progression—what exactly changes in a church when social acceptance and economic opportunity become normal?
Another way to ask: When Mennonites went from persecuted to respected and wealthy, where do you think the big turning point happened? What changes inside a church when being accepted and having money becomes normal?

Direct Answer Dean’s narrative implies the turning point comes when freedom and prosperity become normal, and Mennonites begin to identify with elite status—so that “vision” shifts from suffering faithfulness to social success and comfort.

Support from Transcript:

  • After toleration, Dean describes a new period: “things are very lax…Open. You can be out in the open. You can have your church…businesses,” and “they begin to grow more and more.”
  • He points to economic rise: “they got rich with their shipping,” businesses “grow and grow,” and they become “part of the upper class.”
  • He notes by “1663” there was “hardly anything…preventing the Mennonites” from becoming “high society.”
  • The slide’s translation: “ascend the social ladder…in the 17th and 18th century,” ending “to practically royalty,” including one “knighted” because of “fabulous wealth” and employees.
  • Dean interprets the spiritual shift: “somehow…they started to really lose out a lot of the vision of why they were there in the first place.”
  • Another slide theme: “orthodoxy shrinks,” suggesting fewer hold convictions as status rises.
Discussion Follow-ups What signals would show your church is starting to use the world’s ladder (status, wealth, respectability) as a scoreboard instead of discipleship?

Jumpstarter 5 of 10
Back Questions Next