Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 2 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Radical Reformation History  /  Lecture 11: The Birth of the Amish  /  Discussion Questions
All Questions
Question 2
Lieutenant Heinrich Frick’s conversion is described as a man who found the Bible and asked, “Wow, what if Jesus really meant that?” What does that question assume about the authority of Jesus’ words, and where do modern Christians subtly treat Jesus’ commands as ideals rather than expectations?
Another way to ask: When Frick asks, “What if Jesus really meant that?”, what does that say about how much authority Jesus’ words have? Where do Christians today treat Jesus’ commands as nice goals instead of real commands?

Direct Answer The transcript suggests Frick’s question assumes Jesus’ words carry binding authority, not merely inspiring ideals—so binding that they override patriotic duty and personal safety. Modern Christians can subtly downgrade Jesus’ commands when obedience threatens comfort, reputation, or civic expectations.

Support from Transcript:

  • Dean says Frick “found the Bible… got a hold of the words of Jesus,” and then asked, “Wow, what if Jesus really meant that?”
  • Frick’s response was practical obedience: he “refused… to muster the troops” even though he was a “standard bearer,” a high-honor patriotic role.
  • Dean parallels this with his own convictions in the military, avoiding the anthem/salute and recalling Daniel’s friends who “didn’t bow.”
  • The cost of taking Jesus seriously is emphasized: Frick’s refusal “caused a new wave of persecution,” and later his property was confiscated.
  • Frick’s reasons included “militarism and the oath,” showing Jesus’ teachings were treated as expectations shaping concrete life choices.
Discussion Follow-ups What commands of Jesus become “symbolic” for us when they collide with career, nationalism, or social acceptance? What would change if we assumed Jesus meant what He said?

Jumpstarter 2 of 10
Back Questions Next