Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 8 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 8
Dean’s Baptist church told them, “I think you’d be more comfortable worshiping elsewhere,” after their nonresistance convictions surfaced. What does that reveal about the boundaries of “acceptable Christianity” in some churches, and how should a serious Christian respond when obedience to Jesus costs belonging, friendships, or a spiritual “home”?
Another way to ask: When Dean’s church pushed them out because of nonresistance, what does that show about what some churches consider “acceptable” Christianity? How should a Christian respond when obeying Jesus costs friendships or a church home?

Direct Answer The transcript suggests some churches draw the line of “acceptable Christianity” where convictions begin to challenge normal cultural loyalties, including views of war and discipleship. Dean’s response was not to abandon faith but to pursue obedience and seek grounding in Scripture and history, even if it meant loneliness.

Support from Transcript:

  • After their convictions, Dean says, “Our Baptist church told us, ‘I think you’d be more comfortable worshiping elsewhere,’ was his literal words.”
  • This happened in the context of Dean concluding his world was “contrary to the teachings of Jesus Christ,” especially around enemy-love/nonresistance.
  • He describes the cost: “During that time… I was kind of lonely. Didn’t have much of a church.”
  • Instead of quitting, he says, “history became… a church for me for a while,” as he asked, “Am I crazy? Or has there been other people who thought this way?”
  • He found encouragement that “there has been a lot of people who thought this way,” and that “we have an immense amount of wisdom that we can gain from them.”
  • He frames obedience as central: “I’ve tried to live that idea… believing that he meant every word that he said.”
Discussion Follow-ups When you lose belonging for obedience, what supports keep you from drifting into bitterness or isolation? How can churches make room for costly obedience without immediately pushing people out as “uncomfortable”?