Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion

Question 1

Dean described walking into a Mennonite youth gathering in Germany and being met with “So what?” when he asked, “You’re Mennonites.” What does that reaction reveal about how a church can lose (or reject) the value of its own heritage, and what parts of Anabaptist/Mennonite heritage do you think Dean believes are “more like Christ”?

Another way to ask: When the youth said “So what?” to being Mennonite, what does that show about a church forgetting or rejecting its own history? Which parts of the Anabaptist/Mennonite story do you think Dean sees as “more like Christ”?

Direct Answer The “So what?” response shows a church can become embarrassed by—or indifferent to—its own heritage, treating it as a label instead of a discipleship way of life. Dean implies the heritage matters because some of its emphases are “much more like Christ,” especially taking Jesus’ words as a real-life “design for life.”

Support from Transcript:

Dean says that moment revealed “a non-appreciation of a heritage… a non-understanding of the heritage.”
He adds there’s also “a non-understanding of some of the things that I think are much more like Christ,” and answers “Why is it even important? Because I think it’s more like Christ.”
He ties “Anabaptist difference” to Jesus “opening up the word” and saying, “I mean it… It’s a design for life.”
The specific Christlike emphasis he highlights is obedience to Jesus’ plain teaching (he reads “resist not evil… turn… the other… love your enemy”).
He contrasts this with Christianity as “head knowledge” and calls the Anabaptist genius the question: “What if Jesus really meant every word he said?”

Discussion Follow-ups What parts of your church identity feel like “just a label” instead of a lived obedience? What would it look like to treat heritage as a call to follow Jesus rather than a badge?

Jumpstarter 1 of 10

Add your phone number?

Thank you!

Jumpstarter 1 of 10