Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 2 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 2
Taylor claims that if you don’t grasp “the two kingdoms,” you won’t understand Jesus—and he suggests the church has often struggled to decide “which things go to Caesar and if there’s anything left to give to God”; what specific loyalties, habits, or assumptions in your life reveal confusion about which kingdom you actually belong to?
Another way to ask: Taylor says you can’t understand Jesus without “the two kingdoms.” What loyalties, habits, or assumptions in your life show you may be mixed up about which kingdom you really belong to?

Direct Answer Based on Dean Taylor’s teaching, confusion shows up when my daily priorities and identity feel more rooted in “this current establishment” than in Christ’s kingdom—especially when I treat Jesus’ commands as optional “add-ons” instead of my primary marching orders. The clearest test is whether I “seek first the kingdom of God” or seek first stability, success, and acceptance in the world’s system.

Support from Transcript:

  • Taylor says, “If you don’t get this, you’re not going to get the teachings of Jesus,” tying understanding to kingdom belonging.
  • He observes the church struggles with Caesar/God: deciding “which things go to Caesar and if there’s anything left to give to God.”
  • He describes believers as “sojourners” and “good soldier[s]… not entangled with the affairs of this life.”
  • He illustrates with Germany: living among Germans yet “very clearly Americans,” and not running for “Bergermeister,” because identity was settled.
  • He warns Christianity can become “a social club… I just can’t wait to get to heaven,” which shrinks the Bible’s purpose.
  • He quotes Jesus’ priority: “Seek first the kingdom of God,” applying it to “careers… whatever it is.”
Discussion Follow-ups Where do you feel pressure to prove you “belong” in the nation or culture? Taylor’s lens suggests the pressure itself may reveal which kingdom’s approval you’re chasing.