Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.

The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 7 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 7
Dean describes his frustration with liberal pacifists who “mix up the two kingdoms” through political agendas, and conservative evangelicals who “ignore the teachings of Jesus” by postponing them; where do you recognize yourself gravitating toward one of those two escapes, and what specific teaching of Jesus feels most costly to obey without an escape hatch?
Another way to ask: Do you lean more toward using politics to solve everything, or toward putting off Jesus’ hard teachings? Which teaching of Jesus feels most expensive or risky for you to obey right now?

Direct Answer Dean frames two “escape hatches”: using politics to force peace (mixing kingdoms) or using theology to postpone Jesus’ commands; he pushes believers to face the costly obedience of enemy-love and non-retaliation now.

Support from Transcript:

  • Dean says liberal pacifists were “mixing up the two kingdoms just like the conservative evangelicals did,” especially by pushing “voting in a pacifist president or some other political agenda,” which he calls “nonsense.”
  • He also says many liberal writers were “ignoring the Old Testament,” trying to turn Scripture into “some sort of universalism,” which confused him.
  • On the conservative side, he found they were “just about ignoring the teachings of Jesus,” putting them off into “some millennium… or in heaven,” making Jesus’ teaching “nonsense.”
  • He gives a concrete illustration: build a church that does “everything Jesus said… just the opposite”—and says “you kind of end up with the modern American church,” including “Christians armies.”
  • He repeatedly centers the costly commands: “Repay no one evil for evil,” “do not avenge,” and “feed” and “care” for “enemies of our own nations.”
Discussion Follow-ups Which feels more tempting: political control or theological delay? Dean’s examples invite naming one Jesus-command you’ve learned to sidestep (revenge, lawsuits, enemy-love, possessions, etc.).