Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Discussion Jumpstarter

Study leader reference - not a definitive answer
Sound Faith / Master the Tempest is Raging - Self Taught - Keely Willis
Watch Full Video
Question 3
The lyric, “Carest Thou not that we perish,” puts a charge against Jesus in the mouth of the fearful; what does this teach about the honesty God allows in prayer, and where is the line between raw lament and unbelieving accusation?
Another way to ask: What does “Don’t you care if we die?” teach about being honest with God in prayer? How can you tell the difference between pouring out grief and accusing God in unbelief?
Discussion Jumpstarter

Direct Answer
The hymn shows that fearful people may speak bluntly to Jesus—“Carest Thou not…?”—yet still turn to Him as “Master” who can save. The line between lament and accusation is not fully defined in the transcript, but the hymn implies honest distress should move toward calling on Him to “take control,” not away from trusting Him.

Support from Transcript:
  • The fearful charge is stated plainly: “Carest Thou not that we perish.”
  • The storm feels final: “Each moment so madly is threatening, a grave in the evergreen.”
  • Yet the cry remains directed to Jesus as Lord: the repeated address, “Master,” frames the complaint.
  • In verse two, distress becomes a request: “Awaken and say…” and “Master, all hasten and take control.”
  • The hymn resolves fear through His authority: “The winds and the waves shall obey my will. Peace be still.”
Discussion Follow-ups When you pray in fear, do you aim your words toward Jesus or away from Him? What does it look like to bring honest questions while still asking Him to “take control”?
Jumpstarter 3 of 10
Previous All Questions Next