Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Discussion Jumpstarter

Study leader reference - not a definitive answer
Hope For Wondering Amish / "I Grew Up Old Order Mennonite" ~Jerry Martin
Watch Full Video
Question 3
Jerry admits he tried to “play it safe” morally “just in case there’s a God”; what does that reveal about the difference between fear-based reform and genuine repentance, and how might early Christians have diagnosed that kind of “clean up my life” motivation?
Another way to ask: Jerry tried to live “safe” morally just in case God was real. How is that different from real repentance, and how do you think early Christians would have viewed that kind of motive?
Discussion Jumpstarter

Direct Answer
Jerry’s “play it safe” mindset shows a fear-of-consequences approach that still doesn’t know God or love Him; it’s self-protection more than surrender. The transcript doesn’t directly describe how early Christians would diagnose it, but Jerry himself implies it fell short because he still didn’t “know the way” and kept returning to sin.

Support from Transcript:
  • He describes the motivation plainly: “I better play it safe and clean up my life just in case there’s a God.”
  • The fear is hell-focused, not God-focused: “If there is a God… I’ll go to hell.”
  • Even with that reasoning, he continued “on that road in sin,” suggesting fear-based reform didn’t produce lasting change.
  • He admits he didn’t know how to come to God: “I didn’t know who God was and how to confess my sins and ask Him to help me.”
  • His later turning point is different: an honest prayer—“I don’t really believe I’m living for you”—followed by obedience and spiritual awakening.
Discussion Follow-ups What signs in Jerry’s story distinguish “damage control” from repentance—and how might we gently expose a merely fear-driven morality in ourselves or others?
Jumpstarter 3 of 10
Previous All Questions Next