Skip to content

Add your phone number?

Optional. Nothing is sent unless you choose it.
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Discussion Jumpstarter

Study leader reference - not a definitive answer
Anabaptist Perspectives / William Penn Knew the Mennonites. This Is What He Said. - John Ruth
Watch Full Video
Question 4
Penn tells his secretary, “Treat them with tenderness and love so that they will send over a good character”; what does it mean that Penn connects hospitality to the moral “character” of future immigrants, and how does that logic expose the way harsh treatment can corrupt a community’s reputation and witness?
Another way to ask: Penn links kindness to immigrants having a “good character.” What is he saying about how hospitality affects who comes next, and how can harsh treatment damage a community’s reputation and witness?
Discussion Jumpstarter

Direct Answer
The transcript suggests Penn believed how newcomers are treated will shape the “character” and reputation of the whole immigrant stream that follows. The logic implies that harshness could produce bitterness and a damaged witness, while tenderness encourages a “good character” to be sent and seen.

Support from Transcript:
  • Penn’s instruction is directly quoted: “Treat them with tenderness and love so that they will send over a good character.”
  • The speaker interprets Penn as wanting more Mennonite immigrants: “He wanted more of us,” so hospitality is tied to future migration.
  • Penn’s knowledge is limited—“Undocumented. All he knew was we were Mennonites”—yet he still believes treatment will affect outcomes.
  • The emphasis on public reputation (“good character”) shows hospitality is not merely private kindness but part of communal witness.
Discussion Follow-ups In what ways do churches today shape the kind of people who will want to join them? How might a cold or suspicious welcome change the kind of community we become over time?
Jumpstarter 4 of 10
Previous All Questions Next