Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 4 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 4
Bercot says we should read each verse slowly and ask, β€œIf I didn’t know any better, what would I probably think this verse was saying?” How might that approach expose interpretations that depend more on later theology or church tradition than on the text itself?
Another way to ask: Bercot says we should read each verse slowly and ask, "What would I think this verse means if I had no other ideas already?" How can this show when our views come more from tradition than from the Bible text?

Direct Answer

That approach forces the reader to listen to the immediate wording of each verse before importing a preferred framework. It can expose interpretations that are being carried into the passage rather than drawn from the passage.

Support from Transcript

- Bercot says to β€œread through the passage again very slowly, verse by verse.” - He tells readers to ask, β€œIf I didn’t know any better, what would I probably think this verse was saying?” - He warns that β€œat this stage you do not attempt to harmonize any single verse with any other verses.” - He says the goal is β€œto really listen to what each individual verse or statement of Scripture is saying.” - He describes this as seeking β€œthe literal meaning of each verse, if that verse stood alone.” - He says, β€œThe whole is the sum of the parts,” so no part should be ignored.

Discussion Follow-ups

This method does not solve every ambiguity, as Bercot later admits. But it can reveal whether our first instinct comes from the verse itself or from something already assumed.