Skip to content
The Historic Faith
Sign in

Jumpstarter 7 of 10

Ideas to help restart your discussion
Question 7
Lactantius argues that teaching is “nullified” if the teacher doesn’t live it and that “men prefer examples to words”; in what ways does this expose uncomfortable weaknesses in contemporary preaching cultures (including online teaching, celebrity pastors, and content-driven churches)?
Another way to ask: If teaching doesn’t count when the teacher doesn’t live it, what weaknesses does that point out in today’s preaching world (online teachers, celebrity pastors, and churches built around content)?

Direct Answer Based on the transcript, Lactantius exposes the weakness of teaching that is persuasive in words but not embodied in a visible, consistent life—because hearers instinctively test whether the teacher actually lives what he commands. This challenges any preaching culture where a speaker’s content is valued more than his character and daily example.

Support from Transcript:

  • Lactantius: if the teacher “does not live by [the principles], his teaching is nullified.”
  • He imagines the hearer’s pushback: “First let me see you practice the things you teach, so I will know they are possible.”
  • He argues example is necessary: “How will the teacher take away this excuse…unless he teaches them by his example so they can see…that the things he teaches are possible?”
  • Summary line: “Men prefer examples to words because it is easy to speak but difficult to act.”
  • Bercot ties this to leader qualifications: elders were “proven men” with “established character,” and a man had to be able to “teach by example as well as by word.”
  • Modern contrast in the transcript: many deacons/elders today are not seen as shepherds, while teaching is centralized in a “hired pastor,” which can elevate speech over shared, observable discipleship.
Discussion Follow-ups What structures in a church help members see leaders’ lives up close (and not just their sermons), and what structures hide leaders behind platforms?